When did you last willingly sit through a six-minute advert?

Actually, let me rephrase that. When did you last actively search for an advert, force your work colleagues to gather around a computer screen to watch it and then spend the next ten minutes discussing whether it was any good?

Because that is exactly what we seem to do every Christmas, and I find the whole thing rather fascinating.

We live in a world where we pay extra for ad-free subscriptions, and skip YouTube adverts at the earliest opportunity. Yet, come November, something changes. Suddenly, we’re actively seeking out adverts, sharing them with friends, debating which is the best and, in my case, feeling slightly disappointed when the John Lewis Christmas advert doesn’t make me cry.

And this year, Waitrose has taken things to a whole new level.

 

Six minutes for a supermarket advert. Really?

Yes, really. Waitrose has released what it describes as the longest advert ever produced by a UK supermarket, and at six minutes long, The Perfect Gift 2 is essentially a miniature romantic comedy. We’re talking Keira Knightley, Joe Wilkinson, a love rival, a wedding and a beef Wellington. All the essential ingredients for a Christmas love story, apparently.

It’s also a sequel to last year’s four-minute advert, which makes the whole thing even more interesting. Instead of starting again with a completely new concept, Waitrose has brought back the characters and continued the storyline (it’s giving me Bisto Gravy storyline vibes). And I think it’s genius!

Rather than simply showing us beautifully presented Christmas food (although there’s obviously plenty of that too), they’ve created something people actually want to watch. There are characters to become invested in, a storyline to follow and, importantly, a reason to come back.

I’ve been reading quite a few discussions about it on LinkedIn too, including Jamie Laing praising the casting and comparing the feel-good storytelling to a Gavin & Stacey Christmas special. What struck me wasn’t just the enthusiasm for the advert, but the fact that people were discussing a six-minute supermarket commercial as though it were a television programme they’d been looking forward to.

And if you’ve not seen it yet, go and give it a watch. Enjoy.

Can you imagine telling someone a few years ago that they’d happily spend six minutes of their own time watching a supermarket advert online? Admittedly, if you were talking to me, I’d probably have believed you. But I suspect most people would have questioned your sanity.

Yet here we are.

 

When did Christmas adverts become such a big thing?

I can’t be the only person who used to put a reminder in my calendar for the release of the John Lewis Christmas advert?

There was a time when I genuinely looked forward to it. I’d go onto YouTube, find the full advert and watch it properly, usually hoping for something along the lines of The Man on the Moon or Monty the Penguin that would bring a tear to my eye.

In fact, I did exactly that last week with this year’s advert, Gloria and Pickles, featuring Dame Kristin Scott Thomas and a toy dog voiced by Paul Whitehouse (ain’t milk brilliant casting, by the way).

And, if I’m being picky, I was a little disappointed. Not because it was a bad advert, it was lovely, but because it didn’t make me cry. Which, apparently, is now one of my criteria for judging Christmas advertising. I’m not entirely sure what that says about me, but there we go.

From a marketing perspective, though, it’s quite remarkable what John Lewis has achieved over the years. They’ve managed to turn an annual advertising campaign into something people actively anticipate. The release of their Christmas advert has become part of the festive calendar, somewhere between putting the tree up, sipping a mulled wine, and digging into the After Eight mints.

And I think that says a lot about the power of consistent brand building. John Lewis hasn’t simply produced a series of Christmas adverts. They’ve created an expectation, and people keep coming back to see whether this year’s offering lives up to the last.

Even when it doesn’t make me cry.

 

Perhaps we’re not watching the adverts for the products after all

The more I think about it, the more I wonder whether Christmas advertising works because it stops feeling like advertising.

Most of the year, brands are competing for our attention by telling us what we need, what we’re missing or why their product is better than somebody else’s. But at Christmas, the most memorable campaigns often take a completely different approach.

They tell us stories.

Stories about family, nostalgia, generosity, love and togetherness, usually with a healthy dose of humour and the inevitable chaos that comes with trying to create the perfect Christmas.

We recognise ourselves in some of these situations or at least recognise how they make us feel. It might be a grandparent trying to find the perfect gift, a family coming together or somebody going to extraordinary lengths to make Christmas special.

The products are still there, of course. Nobody spends that sort of advertising budget purely to entertain the nation out of the goodness of their heart. But they’re woven into something much bigger than a straightforward sales message.

And I think that’s why we’re so willing to watch.

Waitrose is a perfect example. Six minutes is a lot of attention to ask for, particularly when most businesses are being encouraged to capture someone’s interest within the first three seconds of a social media video. Yet Waitrose has gone in the opposite direction, creating a story that needs time to develop.

The result is something that feels more like a short film than an advert, and we’re no longer sitting there waiting for the skip button to appear. We actually want to know what happens next.

Which brings me to another question. If we’re enjoying these adverts so much, are they actually influencing what we buy?

 

Will I shop at John Lewis because of their advert? Probably not.

As much as I love the John Lewis Christmas campaigns, I can’t say they’ve ever made me dramatically change my shopping habits. The same goes for Waitrose. I enjoyed the advert, I appreciate the creativity and I’m happy to talk about it, but am I suddenly going to start doing my weekly food shop there?

Probably not. Because, hello! Busy working mum here. Most of my shopping these days involves ordering things online, usually while trying to remember what I’ve forgotten from the previous order.

Maybe when I’m Grandma Gloria I’ll have the time to nip into John Lewis on my pension and buy a ‘feeling’. Until then, convenience is probably going to win.

However, the M&S Christmas advert has had a slightly different effect on me. As I’m sure it has on a few of us, for one reason or another.

This year’s campaign, The Home of Christmas, features James Norton as Father Christmas, alongside Lucy Punch as Mrs Claus. The storyline sees Santa ditch the beard and experience Christmas as the rest of us do, bringing together everything from festive food and family celebrations to gifting and a little seasonal glamour.

And I have to admit, some of that Christmas food looks rather tempting. Amongst other things.

In fact, James Norton made those prawn nibbles look so appealing that I’ve genuinely considered popping into M&S before Christmas. For the food, obviously.

But joking aside, this is where advertising becomes particularly interesting, because all three campaigns have prompted slightly different reactions from me.

John Lewis has strengthened an emotional connection I’ve had with the brand for years. Waitrose has entertained me enough that I’m now writing an entire blog about its advert. And M&S has potentially persuaded me to make an actual purchase.

That’s three very different outcomes, but all three have value.

We often judge marketing by whether it generates an immediate sale, and understandably so, particularly for smaller businesses where budgets need to work hard. But there’s also something to be said for being remembered, talked about and considered.

After all, we don’t always buy something the first time we see it advertised. Sometimes the influence is much more subtle, building over time until we’re ready to make a decision.

Or until James Norton appears with a plate of party food.

 

What does this mean for the rest of us?

Now, I’m fully aware that most SMEs don’t have the marketing budgets of John Lewis, Waitrose or M&S, and I’m certainly not suggesting every business should rush out and produce a six-minute Christmas film starring Keira Knightley.

Although, if the budget allows, why not?

What I do think these campaigns demonstrate is that good marketing isn’t always about pushing a product or service in front of somebody and hoping they’ll buy it. Sometimes it’s about creating a connection, showing a little personality or simply giving people something they enjoy.

And that isn’t exclusive to brands with enormous advertising budgets.

Think about some of the school project ‘John Lewis’ Christmas adverts that have appeared on YouTube over the years. I’ve watched a few that have been genuinely moving, and in some cases I’ve thought they were better than the real thing. They certainly didn’t need celebrity actors or a Hollywood production team to make an impression.

For smaller businesses, storytelling might involve sharing how the company started, introducing the people behind the scenes, celebrating a customer success or talking openly about something that matters to your audience.

It doesn’t need to be complicated, and it certainly doesn’t always need to be Christmas-themed.

The important thing is understanding who you’re talking to and what will make them interested enough to listen.

Of course, there’s still a place for straightforward advertising. If I’m searching for a particular service because I need it urgently, I don’t necessarily want a heartwarming story about the founder’s childhood. I want to know whether the business can help me, how much it costs and how quickly they can get started.

But when the objective is to build awareness, develop trust or create a lasting impression, there’s a lot to be said for taking a more creative approach.

And perhaps that’s something we could all do a little more of.

 

So, is advertising really as annoying as we think?

I started thinking about this blog because of the contradiction between how much effort we put into avoiding adverts and how much enthusiasm we have for watching them at Christmas.

And the more I think about it, the more I wonder whether we don’t actually dislike advertising at all. Perhaps we just dislike advertising that interrupts us without offering anything worthwhile in return.

When an advert entertains us, makes us laugh, tells us a story or creates an emotional connection, we’re suddenly much more willing to give it our attention. We might even go looking for it ourselves.

That’s not to say every Christmas campaign gets it right. There are always a few that leave you wondering how much money somebody spent creating something you’ll have forgotten by Boxing Day. And I’m sure there are plenty of people who are already thoroughly fed up with festive advertising before we’ve even reached December.

But the really good ones have a habit of staying with us for years.

I still remember Monty the Penguin. I still remember The Man on the Moon. And apparently, I’m now going to remember a romantic comedy involving Keira Knightley, Joe Wilkinson and a beef Wellington.

Who’d have thought?

 

Final thought

I’ve always loved a good Christmas advert, but this year’s campaigns have reminded me just how powerful creative advertising can still be, particularly when brands are prepared to do something a little different.

Would I voluntarily spend six minutes watching somebody explain why their supermarket sells the best sprouts? Absolutely not. But give me a romantic storyline, some familiar faces and a bit of festive humour, and apparently I’m more than happy to watch the whole thing.

We spend so much of our time trying to avoid advertising that perhaps the biggest achievement for these brands isn’t getting us to buy something at all. It’s getting us to willingly give them our attention in the first place.

And in a world where attention is becoming increasingly difficult to earn, that’s no small thing.

So perhaps advertising isn’t dead after all. We’ve just become a little more selective about what deserves our time.

As for which advert has actually influenced my Christmas shopping plans this year, well, M&S, I’ll probably see you soon.

I’d love to know what everyone else thinks. What’s your favourite Christmas advert this year? Has one made you laugh, cry or even tempted you to shop somewhere different?

And if this has got you thinking about how your own business could tell its story a little differently, that’s exactly the sort of thing we love discussing at Dialled In. Give us a call on 0114 312 2330 or drop us on email on info@dialledin.com

Merry Christmas!